
Vertex Partnership Academies
RT
@IanVRowe: Thanks for the response.
The “stats” you are focused on - race and gender - mask the overwhelming data that indicates that the family structure within which a child is raised, is far more determinative of that child’s education (and other) outcomes.
There are lots of high-performing black and Asian kids being raised in healthy, married, low-income two-parent households, while simultaneously there are many white kids being raised in unstable, single-parent households that are severely underperforming academically.
Race and gender are “lazy” categories for analysis because they are easily visible/trackable. It’s not that we should ignore those factors. But implying that analyzing outcomes through the prism of family structure is “noise,” then you, like
@cremieuxrecueil , are ignoring a key, frankly obvious factor that has become taboo to discuss.
Unfortunately, this kind of single variable analysis leads to the conclusion that racial gaps must be being driven by racial discrimination and/or racial inferiority, which is repugnant. Other factors matter. It’s unfortunate SATs (and NAEP) do not make it easier to disaggregate student outcomes by family structure.
But we shouldn’t let the lack of data lead us to presume the only factors that matter are the visibly lazy ones like race and gender.