Follow up on 3 weirdly glowing stars
Reconstructed light curves from 100 years+ Harvard photometry, and verified every archive I could data mine
NSVS, ASAS-3, SuperWASP, KELT, ZTF, TESS, NGTS, Gaia DR3 (astrometry, radial velocities, XP spectra), LAMOST and DESI spectra, GALEX ultraviolet, WISE/NEOWISE 2010–2024, 430 SPHEREx images from 2025–26, LoTSS/RACS/NVSS radio, ROSAT and eROSITA X-rays, and ~200 catalogues.
Okay so first what I could confirm.
All three glows are real and sit on the star. For
@fofrAI star, LoTSS radio rules out a background dusty galaxy at 5.6σ. Only a hidden radio-quiet quasar remains, at roughly 1 in 10,000.
There are no companion stars in those systems (aka binaries). Radial velocities from Gaia, LAMOST and DESI are flat to ~1–2 km/s. Gaia astrometry shows no wobble, and Gaia’s spectra rule out a second star down to ~M3.
Next I've checked if something visible (not ruling out a rogue free floating planet) could have passed the system.
I traced every Gaia star with a known velocity back million years: nothing passed close enough to matter. The closest came 0.55 pc from Fofr’s star, 330,000 years ago.
None of those 3 stars is young. Lithium, chromospheric activity and their motion through the Galaxy put them at ~1–8 billion years. Fofr’s star is ~5 Gyr.
J000153: clouds of dust cross the star, dimming it by up to 15%, more in blue light, some dips with comet-like tails. SPHEREx finds ~1,300 K dust at 0.04 AU, where rock evaporates. Its cooler 242 K dust alone is a 300–800 km body ground up.
My leading hypothesis for J000153 is that a dwarf-planet-sized body broke apart in the system. Why? No cle.
J144944: no dips, but its 12 µm glow faded ~15% within six months in 2010. There also is a warm dust.
Fofr’s star is the strange one. Harvard plates from 1894 to 1989, then ASAS-3, SuperWASP, TESS, NEOWISE and SPHEREx up to September 2026: no dimming, no flare, no hot dust, no change.
Yet some object / disc 1.7 AU from her glows at 196 K with 1.3% of her light. Scaled to her light, that’s where our asteroid belt starts. It’s roughly a Vesta ground into dust, ~100,000× more than a 5-billion-year-old system can hold. The grains destroy each other within a few years, so something is refilling it right now.
Comets can’t do it: you’d need tens of thousands of Hale-Bopps at once. A passing star can’t, and a boiling ice world would have to be the size of Neptune. What’s left is big rocky bodies breaking up in her asteroid belt, perhaps planets that stayed stable for billions of years and finally collided. Through all of it, her starlight hasn’t flickered once in 130 years.
On the second image you can see the passing debris on J000153, but nothing like this is present on Fofr's star.
In summary, I have hit the wall here with the available data.
I want to believe that in my lifetime we will find technosignatures, or at least microbial life. But the amount of direct observations you need to rule out every possible natural option is beyond what a solo researcher can do. For now!